Skip to content

Audit trail

A tamper-evident record of every document, from sending to the last signature

A signature is only as useful as the record behind it. For every request, Refrendo keeps who did what, when, to which version, and how they were identified, and hands everyone a completion certificate they can keep with the signed document.

Refrendo is in a closed beta. Beta organisations use it free.

The completion certificate

When the last person acts, Refrendo produces the signed PDF, with every value drawn onto the page so nobody can edit a field afterwards, and a separate completion certificate. Everyone who took part is emailed a link to both, unless the sender turned the certificate off. It records:

The first page of a Refrendo completion certificate: the document, organisation and reference, then each participant with when they approved or signed, how they signed, how they were identified (including an access code), and when they agreed to electronic records.
A real completion certificate, from our demo organisation.

How people are identified

The certificate says, for each person, how Refrendo knew it was them:

Refrendo doesn’t check identity documents, and there are no text-message codes.

A chain the database won’t let anyone edit

Every event on a request is recorded: sent, opened, approved, signed, passed on, reminded, downloaded. Each record notes who, when, which version of the document, the method, the IP address, an approximate location and the device. Views and downloads by your own team are recorded the same way as a guest’s.

Each record carries a hash of the one before it, so changing any record later breaks the chain from that point on. The database itself refuses to edit or delete records, and the request page shows whether the chain verifies.

app.refrendo.com.au
A completed request in Refrendo: fingerprints of the original and completed documents, each director's signature, the copy sent, and the audit trail marked Tamper-evident: chain verified

That makes the audit trail tamper-evident: a change made after the fact can be detected. We don’t call it tamper-proof, because nothing is.

Every version kept

A document is never overwritten. A revision is always a new version with its own fingerprint, and each approval stays tied to the version it was given on. Before producing the signed PDF, Refrendo checks that the original is byte for byte the one that was sent.

Files made to be kept

The certificate is PDF/A-2b (ISO 19005-2), the archival standard: every font is inside the file, so it opens and looks the same for as long as it’s kept. The signed document is PDF/A-2b too when the uploaded file allows it, and the certificate’s Signed document format line says whether it is. To accept only PDFs that can be kept that way, an administrator can require PDF/A for the organisation. Business and above

Anyone downloading the signed document or the certificate can take a password-protected copy to share, with a password they choose or one Refrendo makes. The certificate’s fingerprint is of the original file, not the protected copy. More on PDF/A and protected copies.

How long it’s kept

Download the signed PDF and the certificate when the request completes, and keep them with your own records for as long as you need them. Refrendo keeps them too, for at least the period of the plan the sender was on; the pricing page sets it out.

Keep reading

Questions

Is the certificate on every plan?

Yes. Every completed request comes with a completion certificate and its audit trail, on every plan, including Free.

How do I check a PDF is the one that was signed?

Work out its SHA-256 fingerprint and compare it with the one on the certificate. On a Mac, run shasum -a 256 followed by the file’s name in Terminal; on Windows, run certutil -hashfile followed by the file’s name and SHA256 in Command Prompt. If a single character in the file has changed, the fingerprints won’t match.

Who can see people’s IP addresses?

The sender, and people in the organisation with permission to see audit details. The certificate shows an approximate location instead (a region and country, where it’s known), never the IP address.

Is this a digital signature?

No. Refrendo makes electronic signatures and records the evidence around them. It doesn’t apply a certificate-based (PKI) digital signature to the PDF.

Join the closed beta

Refrendo is invitation-only for now. Organisations in the beta send free for as long as it runs.